A Review of Stuffems Toy Shop Make Your Own Stuffed Animal

Hello friends!

McKayla was having some technical difficulties, so she couldn’t get the guest post in. But, it works out, because I have something exciting to share with you all!

Today, I have a new bear! This guy isn’t Build a Bear though(shocker), so I thought I would give a review of him! Also, there are like, no reviews on Amazon for this brand, so I figured I would share my thoughts on this company.

I decided to buy a new stuffed animal one day. I checked Build a Bear, but I was disappointed with the selection. As I’m sure you can tell by now, I prefer the mini bears to the bigger ones most of the time. But, Build a Bear has such a small selection of bears that size. Well, I decided to check Amazon to see what they had. I found this bear by Stuffems Toy Shop and I knew he would fit right in with my other bears! So, I ordered him, and two days later, here he was!

Anyway, let’s get right into the review!


Here is everything in the package.


It comes with an instruction sheet too.


The stuffing is packed in this bag. It looks like a lot less than it actually is.


Here are all of the contents. You will get one bear, a heart, stuffing, instructions and a birth certificate.


The instructions said that the bear would either have velcro, a zip-tie, or a drawstring. My bear had a zip-tie and velcro. I think it worked out pretty well though.


Anyway, the next step is to fluff the stuffing. It looks like a lot, doesn’t it?


It’s not very hard to put all the stuffing in the bear. I just had to be sure to push the stuffing into the arms and legs.


This is the bear with all of the stuffing from the kit in him.


He wasn’t as firm as I would normally like, so I added some that I had on hand. Not a big deal, but it would have been nice to have a bit more stuffing.


This is also a minor thing, but the velcro snagged the fabric with the zip-tie.


Next, I placed the heart inside.


It was pretty easy to close up the zip-tie.


The back closes up pretty nicely.


My main problem with this bear is that the company advertised it as being the same size as the Build a Bear Minis, and clearly, he’s a bit bigger.


It also said that the bear could share clothes with the BAB minis. Even though I made these clothes myself, they were made to fit BAB minis. I wouldn’t exactly say they fit.


Here are the same clothes on Mischief, an official BAB mini.

As someone who has been buying Build a Bears(both big and mini) for years, I feel qualified to compare this bear to Build a Bears. The quality seems about the same, to be honest. The Stuffems bear was a lot bigger than advertised, so that was a little disappointing. However, with BABs the minis come pre-made. There is no option to stuff them yourself. I like the fact that you can make the Stuffems bear, and it is also very easy. The Stuffems Bear is about $2 more than the BAB one, but that doesn’t account for shipping, or the fact that you get less stuff with the BAB one.

If you really want a mini stuffed animal, I have to recommend the Stuffems one. There’s just so much more to choose from. Overall though, I’m sticking with Build a Bear.

I will probably be getting more Stuffems bears in the future though.


Also, the birth certificate is better quality than the BAB ones. I’ll probably do a DIY Birth certificate post eventually(I’ve only had the photos for it for a year or so…) and I’ll elaborate more on the birth certificates there.

So, this guys name is Tyler, but he’ll go by Tye! You know, because he’s tie-dyed? (Emmie helped me with that genius idea) I’ve yet to decide on a middle or last name, but they’ll come to me eventually.

Anyway, that concludes this little review! I hope you enjoyed, and let me know if you buy one of these bears!

3 thoughts on “A Review of Stuffems Toy Shop Make Your Own Stuffed Animal”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s